Bill,Another re-post of a lingering quoeitsn:Some of the box plots (bottom of p. 5 and middle of p. 6) include outliers dealt with by disconnecting those points from the whisker. Do sixth grade students need to learn the very arbitrary “1.5 times the IQR above the upper median” rule for determining whether a data point is far enough to be considered an outlier? Teaching this convention to sixth graders who are just being introduced to this sort of graph seems far too detailed and isolated from the larger focus of the data standards (and the focus of 6th grade, in general) to justify the time and confusion!The standard itself does not seem to require nor forbid this, but including it in this Progression seems to say that this convention would be fair-game on grade 6 assessments. Please let me know if that was the intent or not! If it wasn't, can a note be included in the Progression stating the standards at grade 6 do not require nor forbid instruction focused on the '1.5 times the IQR above the upper median' rule for determining outliers. This should not be a target on assessments. Without a note like that, teachers will have to spend time, which should be focused on the RP and EE standards instead, teaching this convention to mastery just in case it is ever tested. Thanks,Brian
Posted by Yoletty on March 11, 2013 at 10:39 AM under
0 comments