Search by Keyword
Sign Up Below for our MONTHLY BEATLES TRIVIA QUIZ!
“WHEN I’M SIXTY-FOUR”
(John Lennon – Paul McCartney)
Most people have fond memories of the music they were exposed to by their parents when growing up. However, it seems that most dismiss this music as ‘old fashioned’ as the years go by, preferring whatever style or genre of music became popular during their teen years. But, when in a particularly nostalgic mood, a good deal of respect for these distant memories occasionally surface, viewing their parents music as the historic soundtrack of their childhood.
If you happen to choose to make your living as a songwriter, these early remembrances probably can’t help but creep into your consciousness and emerge from time to time in your compositions without your even knowing it. Interestingly, Paul McCartney chose to pay particular homage to these early childhood memories by writing a song directly influenced by these sounds and styles, not feeling a bit of embarrassment in the process.
Achieving the stature that The Beatles had by late 1966, he realized that whatever they would release would be accepted. Even a nostalgic trip back to the 20’s. And taken within the context of being a throw-back of the original “Sgt. Pepper” band, as well as occurring on the scene just after the recent #1 novelty hit “Winchester Cathedral” by the New Vaudeville Band, which appeared as coming from this same by-gone era, Paul’s intuition was correct. While viewed cooley by many die-hard Beatles fans, it eventually won the hearts of their parents as well as becoming an intrinsic element of the “Sgt. Pepper” album.
The Jimmy Mac Jazz Band photo, the precursor to the "Sgt. Pepper" cover
“My dad was an instinctive musician,” related Paul in the book “Anthology.” “He’s played trumpet in a little jazz band when he was younger. I unearthed a photo in the 60’s which someone in the family had given me, and there he is in front of a big bass drum. That gave us the idea for ‘Sgt. Pepper’: ‘The Jimmy Mac Jazz Band.’ My dad is sitting there as a 24-year-old in his tux…Dad played the trumpet until his teeth gave out…He would play the piano at home. We always had a piano…I have some lovely childhood memories of lying on the floor and listening to my dad play ‘Lullaby Of The Leaves’ (still a big favorite of mine), and music from the Paul Whiteman era, old songs like ‘Stairway To Paradise.’”
“He played piano from when I was born,” Paul relates about his father Jim McCartney. “To this day, I have a deep love for the piano, maybe from my dad: it must be in the genes…He was my musical education. There was none in school, we never got music lessons. He would always point out thinks like the chord changes at the beginning of ‘Stairway To Paradise’…Dad was a pretty good self-taught pianist, but because he hadn’t had training himself, he always refused to teach me…In the end, I learnt to play by ear, just like him, making it all up.”
“I’d started fiddling around on my dad’s piano,” Paul remembers. “I wrote ‘When I’m Sitxy-Four’ on that when I was still sixteen (it was all rather tongue in cheek) and I never forgot it. I wrote that tune vaguely thinking it could come in handy in a musical comedy or something. Like I say, I didn’t know what kind of career I was going to take back then…I wasn’t necessarily looking to be a rock’n’roller. When I wrote ‘When I’m Sixty-Four’ I thought I was writing a song for Sinatra. There were records other than rock’n’roll that were important to me. And that would come out in The Beatles doing songs like ‘Till There Was You.’”
Although Paul states above, and elsewhere, that he wrote the song when he was sixteen (1958), this appears to contradict statements made elsewhere. For instance, there are various quotes from Paul indicating that the song was written before the 'rock and roll' boom of 1956. "Rock and roll was about to happen that year, it was about to break. I was still a little bit cabaret minded," Paul stated in 1987. "I wrote a lot of stuff thinking I was going to end up in the cabaret, not realizing that rock and roll was particularly going to happen. When I was fourteen there wasn't that much of a clue that it was going to happen," he recalled in 1974. Historically, the advent of 'rock and roll' music in Liverpool came with the release of "Heartbreak Hotel" around May of 1956, not to mention that by 1958, Paul had already met and partnered up with John, both of their love for 'rock and roll' solidifying their friendship. Therefore, Paul's mention of age 14 in the above quote, which would make it 1956, appears to be more accurate for the initial writing of what became "When I'm Sixty-Four."
But how much of the song had been written when Paul was 14? "I never did anything with it until I was about 24 and then we put the words to it,” he once stated. In 1984, he said: “It was kind of a cabaret tune. Then, years later, I put words to it.” Even in his book “Many Years From Now,” his quote is a little unclear about the matter: “I thought it was too vaudevillian, so I had to get some cod lines to take the sting out of it, and put the tongue very firmly in cheek.” Quotes like this have led some writers to believe that the 1956 rendition of “When I’m Sixty-Four” was instrumental only.
John’s quotes, however, are quite a help to clear up the confusion. In 1967 he stated: “Paul wrote this when we was in The Cavern. We’ve just wrote a few more words on it, like “grandchildren on your knee,’ and stuck in ‘Vera, Chuck and Dave.’ It was just one of those ones that he’d had, that we’ve all got, really - half a song. And this was just one of those that was quite a hit with us. We used to do them when the amps broke down, just sing it on the piano.”
Former Beatles drummer Pete Best has also gone on record to say that he remembers “When I’m Sixty-Four” being played by Paul on piano whenever the electricity went out or the amps broke down. And since it was being sung, as stated above by John, a certain portion of the lyrics had to have been written by then. And, as Paul has stated above, he referred to the originally written song as "tongue in cheek" and for possible inclusion in a "musical comedy." He surely wouldn't have said that if there were no lyrics written yet.
As for finishing the writing of the song in preparation for recording, which is presumed to have been done around November of 1966, Paul explains it this way: “’When I’m Sixty-Four’ was a case of me looking for stuff to do for ‘Pepper.’ I thought it was a good little tune…’Will you still need me?’ is still a love song. ‘Will you still look after me,’ okay, but ‘Will you still feed me?’ goes into ‘Goon Show’ humor. I mean, imagine having three kids called ‘Vera, Chuck and Dave!’ It was very tongue in cheek and that to me is the attraction of it. I liked ‘indicate precisely what…’ I like words that are exact, that you might find on a form. It’s a nice phrase, it scans.”
Many writers suggest that it was written precisely to coincide with his father’s 64th birthday, which was on July 2nd, 1966. Paul himself puts this thought to rest. “My dad was probably only 56 when I wrote it. Retirement age in Britain is 65, so maybe I thought 64 was a good prelude. But probably 64 just worked well as a number.”
As to whether John Lennon actually made any contribution to the song, the assorted quotes are a little sketchy. “It’s pretty much my song,” Paul insists in his book “Many Years From Now.” “I think I helped with some of the words,” John said in 1972. He completely distanced himself from the song in 1980, however, by saying: “Paul’s completely. I would never dream of writing a song like that. There’s some things I never think about, and that’s one of them.” The conclusion, therefore, is that John had very little, if any, involvement in the writing of “When I’m Sixty-Four.”
After extensive work on “Strawberry Fields Forever” for a couple of weeks, thinking it was complete (which it wasn’t), they turned their attention to the second song intended for the new unnamed album, which was “When I’m Sixty-Four.” Being that “Strawberry Fields” was pulled from the sessions for their next single and wasn’t on the forthcoming “Sgt. Pepper” album, “Sixty-Four” was therefore the first song actually recorded for the album.
The Beatles entered EMI Studio Two at 6:45 pm on December 6th, 1966 to begin work on the song, the first duties of the day, however, being recording taped Christmas messages for ‘pirate’ radio stations “Radio London” and “Radio Caroline.” After this was finished, the group started rehearsing how they were going to present “When I’m Sixty-Four” on tape. “Because the group was already so familiar with the song,” explains engineer Geoff Emerick in his book “Here, There And Everywhere,” “the backing track was laid down in just a couple of hours.”
After some time was spent rehearsing the arrangement of the song, The Beatles took to officially laying down a rhythm track. Only two ‘takes’ of the song needed to be recorded to get the rhythm track down properly, the second take being deemed the best, although it was recorded in a piece-meal fashion. "Track one" of the four-track tape contained Paul on bass, Ringo on kick drum and hi-hat only, and John on electric guitar. Then, Paul overdubbed himself on piano on "track two" of the tape while Ringo recorded brushed snare drum on track three. While George was present on this day, evidenced by his voice being heard on the Christmas messages taped earlier in the session, he apparently did not participate in the recording of the song at this point. This completed the session for the day, no vocals being added at all yet. At 1:50 am the following morning, they left the studios and took the next day off.
The next session for “When I’m Sixty-Four” was on December 8th, 1966 in EMI Studio One, the session only lasting three hours, from 2:30 to 5:30 pm. Only one Beatle was present during this session since only one was needed. Paul booked this time to record his lead vocals onto the existing rhythm track. One noteworthy feature of this single-tracked vocal was the audible smile in Paul’s voice just before the last line of the final verse; possibly in reaction to John’s previously recorded lead guitar passages which, while done tastefully, are somewhat out of place for a song that was meant as a throw-back to the music of the 20’s. How many songs from that era have an electric lead guitar solo? This scaled down version of "When I'm Sixty-Four," with jovial vocal hijinks from Paul at the end, can be heard as a bonus track on the 2017 released 50th Anniversay Editions of the "Sgt. Pepper" album. You'll notice here that the tempo is somewhat slower since the recording was slightly sped up at the mixing stage, as we'll discuss later.
The next three sessions booked for the group saw much work being done on a re-make of “Strawberry Fields Forever,” with “When I’m Sixty-Four” being left off for a little later. December 20th, 1966 was when that later time came, this session beginning at 7 pm in EMI Studio Two. All four Beatles were present this time around, Paul, George and John recording the background harmonies heard in the bridges of the song. Ringo had the duty of strategically adding the sound of orchestral bells in the bridges as well. In order to prepare the recording for more overdubs, two attempts at a tape reduction was made to clear up more tracks, the second attempt (labeled ‘take four’) was deemed the best. By 1 am the following morning, the session was complete.
It possibly was at this session, if not before, that Paul discussed with George Martin what was needed to complete the song. “As was usual for a McCartney song,” Geoff Emerick continues, “there were extensive discussions with George Martin about arrangement. Paul kept saying that he wanted the song to be really ‘rootie-tootie,’ so George suggested the addition of clarinets.” Paul adds: “I did it in rooty-tooty variety style…George helped me on a clarinet arrangement. I would specify the sound and I love clarinets so ‘Could we have a clarinet quartet?’ ‘Absolutely.’ I’d give him a fairly good idea of what I wanted and George would score it because I couldn’t do that. He was very helpful to us.”
The next day, December 21st, 1966, was the day that the clarinetists were hired to play George Martin’s score for “When I’m Sixty-Four.” Paul was undoubtedly present for this session, he maybe being the only Beatle interested in the performance of clarinetists. Paul, however, didn’t quite get his “quartet,” since only three musicians were needed for the prepared score, these being Robert Burns, Henry MacKenzie and Frank Reidy. “I scored it for two clarinets and a bass clarinet,” George Martin remembers in his book “All You Need Is Ears.”
“The clarinets on that track became a very personal sound to me,” relates Geoff Emerick. “I recorded them really close up, bringing them so far forward that they became one of the main focal points.” As was usual for professional studio musicians, they nailed the performance in a very short time, the session being complete in only two hours, from 7 to 9 pm. “I remember recording it in the cavernous Number One studio at Abbey Road,” George Martin continues, “and thinking how the three clarinet players looked as lost as a referee and two linesmen alone in the middle of Wembly Stadium.” George’s recollections were incorrect since the session was in the smaller EMI Studio Two, but the point is taken just the same.
Just after the session was complete, an hour was spent in the control room of EMI Studio Two (9 to 10 pm) to take the first stab at creating a mono mix for the song. Three attempts were made by George Martin, Geoff Emerick and 2nd engineer Phil McDonald, but these were made for demo use only and were not intended for the finished album.
The first try at making a useable mono mix of the song was on December 29th, 1966 in the control room of EMI Studio Three by the same production team of Martin, Emerick and McDonald. Four attempts were made on this day, remixes 4 through 7, ‘take 6’ being marked as “best” for the US and ‘take 7’ as “best” for Britain. However, all this work was in vain.
According to Mark Lewisohn’s book “The Beatles Recording Sessions,” “The remixes of ‘When I’m Sixty-Four’ done on 29 December…did not satisfy Paul. He suggested that they scrap all previous mixes and start again, speeding up the new mix to raise it by as much as a semitone, a bit difference.” The new mono mix, created by Paul’s specifications, was done the next day, December 30th, 1966, in the control room of EMI Studio Two by the same production team of Martin, Emerick and McDonald. They only needed one try, ‘remix 8’ being the keeper and used for the mono version of the “Sgt. Pepper” album in both the US and Britain.
But why did Paul want the mono mix to be speeded up? “During the mix," says Geoff Emerick, "Paul also asked to have the track sped up a great deal – almost a semitone – so that his voice would sound more youthful, like the teenager he was when he originally wrote the song.” George Martin inferred similarly in print, but Paul remembers is differently. “George Martin in his book says that I had it speeded up because I wanted to appear younger but I think that was just to make it more rooty-tooty; just lift the key because it was starting to sound a little turgid.”
At the turn of the new year, a decision was being made to issue a new single and “When I’m Sixty-Four,” it appears, may have been considered. “Brian was desperate to recover popularity,” George Martin recalls, “and so we wanted to make sure that we had a marvelous seller. He came to me and said, ‘I must have a really great single. What have you got?’ I said, ‘Well, I’ve got three tracks – and two of them are the best tracks they’ve ever made. We could put the two together and make a smashing single.’ We did, and it was a smashing single – but it was also a dreadful mistake. We would have sold far more and got higher up in the charts if we had issued one of those (“Strawberry Fields Forever” and “Penny Lane”) with, say ‘When I’m Sixty-Four’ on the back.”
Paul’s book “Many Years From Now” confirms this and specifies that “initially the single was to be ‘Strawberry Fields Forever’ backed with ‘When I’m Sixty-Four.’” The EMI documentation for the date January 2nd, 1967 show this as well, as tape copies were made of the recently made mono mixes for both “When I’m Sixty-Four” and “Strawberry Fields Forever” with the intended purpose being for the US, standard procedure for a new Capitol single release in the states.
The stereo mix of the song that was issued worldwide in 1967 wasn’t made until April 17th, 1967 in the control room of EMI Studio Two by George Martin, Geoff Emerick and 2nd engineer Richard Lush. Lush remembers listening to the mono mix on this day as a guide which caused George Martin to question the speed it was recorded. “He kept saying, ‘Surely it can’t have been that fast?,’” Lush recalls. They acquiesced and sped up the stereo mix just the same. The rhythm track, including the piano overdub, was centered in the mix, while the lead vocals and orchestral bells were panned entirely to the left. The clarinets and the harmony vocals are all panned exclusively to the right channel.
Another stereo mix was made sometime in 1999 for release on the album “Yellow Submarine Songtrack.” This mix, which took them back to the actual master tapes, was made at Abbey Road Studios by Peter Cobbin, Paul Hicks, Mirek Stiles and Allan Rouse. The stereo landscape is quite different here, all vocals (lead and harmony) being centered in the mix with the clarinets panned mostly in the right channel, but not entirely. The rhythm track is still centered but the piano overdub and the orchestral bells are only heard in the left channel.
The untimate stereo mix of the song, however, was made sometime in 2016 or 2017 by George Martin's son Giles Martin and engineer Sam Okell for the 50th Anniversary editions of the "Sgt. Pepper" album. Along with this vibrant stereo mix, patterned after the favorable mono mix, Giles went back to the original session tapes to prepare of mix of "take two" of the song in order to get an early glimpse of its recording.
Song Structure and Style
Being that Paul wrote the melody of this song so early in life, not to mention it being a pastiche of the 1920’s, the structure is pretty straight forward and quite similar to most of the early Lennon/McCartney catalog. It consists of a ‘verse/ bridge/ verse/ bridge/ verse’ format (or ababa) with an intro and conclusion thrown in. There is no chorus or refrain but the final measures of each verse act as the hook-line and contain the song’s title as do a plethora of early Beatles tracks (see “Please Please Me,” “I Saw Her Standing There” and “Can’t Buy Me Love” as a few of many examples).
A simple introduction begins proceedings which highlight the clarinets, the bass clarinet holding down the ‘oom-pah’ style bass line while the other two clarinets harmonizing the characteristic introductory melody line, which is a slight alteration from the opening melody line of the verses (“When I get older, losing my hair…”). The only other instrumentation on this introduction is Paul on bass and Ringo playing his snare with brushes. This introduction is actually six measures long, the first four measures finishing out the introductory melody line and then coming to a halt midway through the fourth measure (another ‘Beatles break’) which, when repeated in the conclusion of the song, becomes the ending beat. In the intro, however, another two measures are included as if to keep us in anticipation for when the singer happened to be ready to begin. The bass clarinet includes a small anticipatory frill at the end of the fifth measure to add a touch of vaudevillian flair.
The first sixteen-measure verse comes next, with Paul’s vocal coming in directly on the downbeat. All three clarinets hold out a harmonized chord as a backdrop to the first vocal line, one of them playing a simple progression to fill in the gap as Paul takes a breath in the fourth measure. The fifth measure brings in the piano for the first time playing a simple choppy chord pattern on the quarter notes while the clarinets perform another simple harmony chord in the background. The sixth measure shows Ringo playing a classy fill on the brushes to introduce the ‘break’ in the seventh measure, which leaves only Paul on vocals and bass to fill out the line “birthday greetings, bottle of wine.”
The second half of the verse brings in the same arrangement of instruments as did the beginning four measures but with some additional chord changes in the eleventh and twelfth measures. The piano never returns in the verse but, instead, the clarinets play choppy quarter note harmonies through the quickly changing chord pattern of the final four measures. The sixteenth measure has Ringo showing off on the brushes once again and ending with a tap on his open hi-hats while the bass clarinet plays a fast moving figure to round out the verse.
An odd numbered seventeen-measure bridge is now heard which appears to be an instrumental break because of the first four measures being without Paul’s vocals, only John, Paul and George’s harmony ‘ooh’s being heard in the second through fourth measures. The bridge is a nice contrast to the verses by being in a minor key, Ringo limited to only beating the bass drum, and the piano overdub being heard throughout its entire length. Another feature of the first four measures of the bridge is the harmonized clarinet melody line which works nicely with the vocal harmonies. The fifth measure brings in the lead vocals which appear as an afterthought in this bridge, being that the vocal lines are very scant and are rather meaningless to the storyline of the song. The background vocalists switch to a tightly arranged “aah” melody line as a backwash to the proceedings of the sixth through eighth measures. The drums even back out of the picture in the seventh and eighth measure to give the harmonies more prominence.
The harmonies then vanish for the second half of the bridge while one of the clarinets play a dated sour high note in their harmonized line at the beginning of the ninth measure to fill the gap before Paul begins singing again in the tenth measure. The twelfth measure introduces Ringo on orchestral bells with an ascending three note run and then on the downbeat of each remaining measure of the bridge. Ringo also adds some tinkering on his cymbals from the thirteenth through fifteenth measures to keep his hands busy during the rhythm track. The sixteenth and seventeenth measure brings in another ‘Beatles break’ with some interesting syncopated interplay between the clarinets, bass and Ringo’s orchestral bells.
The second verse then commences which is fully identical instrumentally to the first with the addition of one clarinet run in the eighth measure during the vocal line “go for a ride.” The bridge that follows it, however, changes things up quite a bit more. For one thing, Paul sings a vocal line that is much more involved rhythmically and thought out lyrically. The background vocalists chime in only during the sixth through eighth measures with the line “we shall scrimp and save” which mimics the ‘aah’ melody line from the first bridge. Ringo’s cymbal tinkering begins in the tenth measure this time around while his orchestral bell hits are much more syncopated this time. Also, notice Paul’s rolling of the r’s in the line “grrrandchildren on yourrr knee.”
The final verse is next heard which adds a couple more elements from the previous ones, the first being a clarinet line harmonizing with Paul’s vocal melody. The second element is John on electric guitar which is first detected in the fifth measure and is heard through till the end of the verse. John meanders around a little stylistically, even adding a ‘blue note’ in the twelfth measure, not unlike what is heard at the end of the chorus of “I Wanna Be Your Man” and in the second bridge of “Yesterday.” This appears to put a smile on Paul’s face as he sings the final line of the song in a campy 20’s style with a throwback “hooo” at the end.
Then we hear a four-measure conclusion which is actually a repeat of the first four measures of the intro, the only difference being Ringo playing on the cymbals instead of brushes on his snare and a final two chords on the piano.
Paul has quite an easy job as a musician on this track, his bass playing being probably the simplest of his bass performances on the “Sgt. Pepper” album. His vocal work, while appearing effortless, is performed single-tracked and done suitably for the occasion. Ringo should be next up for mention because of his excellent adaptation to the post-WW1 style of drumming and putting in a more-than-adequate performance on bells. George may have been less involved (sitar just wouldn’t have worked here) but he showed himself up for the vocal challenge with his harmonies as did John. And three cheers also to John for insisting on putting his two cents in on guitar even when it could have been done without. He showed himself similarly cooperative on Paul’s “White Album” “granny music” gem “Honey Pie” a year-and-a-half later.
While many may scratch their heads as to whether Paul is singing to someone he’s currently living with or someone he hardly knows, it appears that the comedic “goon show” sentiments of the song needn’t be analyzed that closely. Basically Paul, being a teenager at the time, is lampooning the lifestyle of people in the autumn of their life, giving a ‘surfacy’ estimation of the uncertainty of old age.
It’s interesting how the older generation gets ‘a kick’ out of this seemingly charming song about growing old. A song sung in this style which begins with the lyrics “when I get older, losing my hair” may give them a chuckle, but the signature line of the “postcard” mentioned in the final verse being, “yours sincerely, Wasting Away” may be just a little too morbid to fit the criteria of a cute sing-along for the oldsters.
That having been said, the continuing of sending a “valentine,” giving “birthday greetings” and hoping their spouse will still “need” and “feed” them is enough to keep them tapping their feet. The depictions of usefulness in older age, such as “mending a fuse,” “knit a sweater” and “doing the garden, digging the weeds” sounds like a fulfilling life for the song’s intended audience, even though Paul undoubtedly brought this all up to show how mundane and meaningless life is when reduced to this. “Who could ask for more,” he sarcastically asks.
At least they can “scrimp and save” to go “every summer” to the same rented “cottage in the Isle Of Wight” and enjoy their strangely named “grrrandchildren,” namely “Vera, Chuck and Dave.”
June 2nd, 1967 was the US release date for the landmark album “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band.” Positioning “When I’m Sixty-Four” after the religiously heady “Within You Without You” was quite startling for the listener, although it did wonders in displaying the immense variety of musical styles The Beatles were capable of by 1967.
In 1978, the album got quite an unusual release, this being as a picture disc with the front cover on the a-side and a close-up of the “Pepper” drum head on the b-side.
The album got its first compact disc release on September 21st, 1987. It was then re-released in a re-mastered state on September 9th, 2009.
Although “When I’m Sixty-Four” missed out being released as a single in 1967, it finally did become a single in the US on January 24th, 1996. This “For Jukebox Only” red vinyl single on the Capitol Cema series had the song as the b-side to “Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds” and is quite the collectable today.
On September 13th, 1999, the album “Yellow Submarine Songtrack” was released in the states which, as mentioned above, featured a newly re-mixed and re-mastered version of “When I’m Sixty-Four” which re-positions some of the elements to create a more modern stereo landscape. The vibrancy of the track is much better as well.
For those interested in hearing the original 1967 mono mix of the song, it was released on CD for the first time in the elaborate box set “The Beatles In Mono” on September 9th, 2009
On May 26th, 2017, a newly mixed stereo version of the album was released based on the superior mono mix of 1967. A new vibrant mix of "When I'm Sixty-Four" is included in all editions of this re-release. In addition, "take two" is contained as a bonus track on both the "2 CD Anniversay Edition" and the "Super Deluxe Edition" box set..
Paul and John at The Cavern Club, Liverpool, circa 1962
While not really considering it to be suitable for his new group The Beatles, Paul did take advantage of the misfortunes of having their amps go out, or the electricity going down, to run through the song on piano while at The Cavern Club or even during their many residencies in Hamburg. While no taped performance exists, Mark Lewisohn’s book “The Complete Beatles Chronicle” lists them performing the song during the years 1960 through 1962. Paul was proud to revive these memories and complete the song for recording purposes in late 1966, but their touring days were over at that point and it was never brought to another Beatles stage.
Paul with brother (Michael), mother (Mary) and father (Jim), cira 1940's
The novelty technique that Paul demonstrated on “When I’m Sixty-Four” gained enough notoriety that he thought to reprise it on two later occasions in The Beatles catalog. The first was a semi-nostalgic approach as delivered in 1967’s “Your Mother Should Know” and then another full-blown flashback to yesteryear on 1968’s “Honey Pie,” clarinets and all. As with all sequels, no matter the medium, the original most often has the biggest impact and is the most popular. A true test that this is the case with “When I’m Sixty-Four” would be to ask any parent of a first-generation Beatles fan if they have a favorite Beatles song. I would venture to guess that this song would be one of the first to come to their minds…along with “Yesterday” of course.
Although Paul desisted from continuing to display his secret passion for his father’s style of music for the remainder of the group’s life (undoubtedly steered away from it by John’s attitude of it being “granny music shit”), he felt strongly enough about it to bring it back during his Wings days. Both “You Gave Me The Answer” and “Baby’s Request” do well to harken back to the likes of “When I’m Sixty-Four,” but as serious pieces of music without the humor. While all of these other songs work nicely and are well written, as one would usually expect of Paul, “When I’m Sixty-Four” seems to epitomize the style and feeling of the era the best. So much so, in fact, that Julian Lennon’s version of the song, as used beautifully in a 2002 Allstate television commercial, shows the composition as nothing short of irresistible.
“When I’m Sixty-Four”
Written by: John Lennon / Paul McCartney
Song Written: 1956, completed November, 1966
Song Recorded: December 6, 8, 20 & 21, 1966
First US Release Date: June 2, 1967
US Single Release: Capitol Cema #S7-18896
Highest Chart Position: n/a
Key: D flat major
Producer: George Martin
Engineers: Geoff Emerick, Phil McDonald
Instrumentation (most likely):
Paul McCartney - Lead and Harmony Vocals, Bass Guitar (1964 Rickenbacker 4001 S), Piano (Hamburg Steinway Baby Grand)
John Lennon - Lead Guitar (1965 Epiphone Casino ES-230TD), Harmony Vocals
Ringo Starr - Drums (1964 Ludwig Super Classic Black Oyster Pearl), Orchestral Bells
George Harrison - Harmony Vocals
Henry MacKenzie - Clarinet
Written and compiled by Dave Rybaczewski
Sign Up Below for our MONTHLY BEATLES TRIVIA QUIZ!