Search by Keyword
Sign Up Below for our MONTHLY BEATLES TRIVIA QUIZ!
“WHAT GOES ON?”
(John Lennon – Paul McCartney – Richard Starkey)
On October 13th, 1965, Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr drove over to John Lennon’s Kenwood home in Weybridge, Surrey with one important order of business. This was to compose a three-way collaborative effort for inclusion on their upcoming album “Rubber Soul.” They all sat down at the kitchen table with paper and pens and, with guitars in hand, wrote what would become the first and only three-person Beatles composition, the results being the Grammy-award winning song “What Goes On?”
Well…OK, it didn’t really happen that way. In fact this is the farthest from the truth. While the real story is hardly as glamorous, it has become a piece of history if only for the reason of it being an indelible component of The Beatles catalog. Not the topper of anyone’s “favorites” list and considered by most as “album filler,” examination shows the song as effectively conveying a convincing message within the framework of a well-written melody line and chord structure. Maybe we all need to reconsider its worth.
John Lennon, circa 1972
When asked in 1972 by Hit Parader magazine who wrote “What Goes On?,” John Lennon answered: “Me. A very early song of mine.” In 1980, he explained to Playboy magazine, “That was an early Lennon, written before The Beatles, when we were The Quarry Men, or something like that.”
“The Quarry Men,” named after Quarry Bank High School where John and most of the original members attended, had a performance life between 1957 and 1960. Paul McCartney joined the group in July of 1957 as did George Harrison in 1958. By 1960, the bands’ name changed various times (“Johnny And The Moondogs,” “The Silver Beetles”) so the song “What Goes On?” apparently was written during this four year time period, although it was never performed by the group.
However, it apparently was quite different than what we’ve come to know it as. Lennon told Playboy in 1980 that the song was “resurrected with a middle-eight thrown in, probably with Paul’s help, to give Ringo a song and also to use the bits, because I never like to waste anything.” John and Paul usually referred to a songs’ bridge as a “middle-eight” but in this case, “What Goes On?” doesn’t have one. It has a repeatable chorus (“What goes on in your heart…”) and a set of verses (“The other day I saw you as…”). It can easily be assumed that what John claims to have written during the Quarry Men days was the chorus while the verses were added by Paul in 1965 to complete it for the “Rubber Soul” album.
This hypothesis brings us to a puzzling conclusion, though. It seems very unlikely that John would only have a repeatable chorus and claim it as a complete song. And since, as we’ll discuss later, the song was auditioned as a contender to be recorded in EMI Studios in 1963 before Paul contributed anything, it must have had at least a little more substance to it early on.
This is cleared up from John’s further comment to Hit Parader magazine in 1972: “Ringo and Paul wrote a new middle-eight together when we recorded it.” Since what was written to complete the song in 1965 was termed a “new middle-eight,” John must have written one in the song’s early version, one that was replaced in 1965 just before it was recorded.
Also clarified here is that Ringo did in fact contribute to the song’s writing, Paul and himself putting together the verses. Barry Miles, in his co-authored autobiography of Paul’s career entitled “Many Years From Now,” states about the song: “John dusted it off and Paul and Ringo wrote a new middle eight for it.” When asked in 1966 about his input to this collaboration, Ringo replied, “I contributed about five words to ‘What Goes On.’ I haven’t done a thing since.”
George Martin with The Beatles in EMI Studio Two, March 5th, 1963
“I was always saying to The Beatles, ‘I want another hit, come on, give me another hit.’” This comment from George Martin was particularly valid in the early months of 1963 when a follow-up to their first British chart-topper “Please Please Me” was needed. Therefore, on March 5th, 1963, at around 2:30 in the afternoon, the group assembled for a session in EMI Studio Two to show him what they had.
George Martin remembers, “I would meet them in the studio to hear a new number. I would perch myself on a high stool and John and Paul would stand around me with their acoustic guitars ans play and sing it – usually without Ringo or George, unless George joined in the harmony. Then I would make suggestions to improve it, and we’d try it again. That’s what is known in the business as a ‘head arrangement.’”
On this occasion, The Beatles premiered four songs to George Martin for consideration for their next single, two newly written compositions and two written many years before. The two first chosen by Martin were the recently written numbers, “From Me To You” and “Thank You Girl,” the former becoming their next British #1 single and the latter becoming its b-side. With a little studio time left, one of the older written songs began life in the studio, this being “One After 909,” although this was never finished nor released at the time. The other older written song that they didn’t have time for that day was the early incarnation of “What Goes On?,” at this time a full John Lennon composition. At this point, this song was the least suitable for recording and apparently didn’t get past the George Martin “high stool” test.
With just over half of the “Rubber Soul” album completed by November 4th, 1965, and with a December 3rd release date fast approaching, the group prepared “What Goes On?” to finally be suitable for recording and release. With a new set of verses written by Paul and Ringo in tow, they entered EMI Studio Two on this day at 11 pm for a late night session to get more needed work done for the album.
Much preparatory work was first needed, so with all the arrangement bugs worked out, they recorded only one take of the rhythm track which was deemed good enough. The instrumentation consisted of John on electric rhythm guitar, George on lead guitar, Paul on bass and Ringo on drums as well as a guide vocal off microphone to guide the song along. Also noticeable on the rhythm track is off-the-cuff remarks and voices from the other group members, such as John yelling out “I already TOLD you why” after Ringo sings “tell me why” at the end of the second verse (most likely a reference to their 1964 composition “Tell Me Why.”
With this rhythm track complete, overdubs commenced. First was Ringo’s lead vocals which remained single-tracked (his fiasco double-tracking “Matchbox” in June of 1964 showed him not too capable with this procedure) and John and Paul’s harmonized background vocals. A small lead guitar flourish at the conclusion of the song was the only instrumental overdub necessary. By approximately 2 am the next morning, “What Goes On?” was complete, leaving the remaining hour-and-a-half hours of the session for attempting the recording of an ad-libbed instrumental tentatively titled “12-Bar Original” which was eventually discarded as a bad idea and never saw the light of day (until “Anthology 2,” that is).
Both the mono and stereo mixes of “What Goes On?” were created on November 9th, 1965 in Room 65 of EMI Studios by George Martin and engineers Norman Smith and Jerry Boys. Interestingly, the overdubbed lead guitar flourish, which presumably was recorded on a separate track, was inadvertently left out of the mono mix. They remembered to turn up this track during the stereo mix which also gives more clarity to Ringo humming/singing the chorus during the guitar solo and his off-mic twice repeated “in your mind” at the end of the song. The stereo mix features most of the rhythm track and Ringo’s lead vocals primarily on the left channel with George’s lead guitar and the overdubbed harmony vocals primarily on the right channel.
In 1986, George Martin created a new stereo mix of the song in preparation for the “Rubber Soul” album appearing on compact disc for the first time. Although somewhat clearer, the mix is essentially the same as the 1965 stereo mix except that both Ringo’s vocals and the background vocals are slightly panned a little bit more to the center.
On July 16th, 2006, Ringo and his “All-Starr Band” had a live rendition of the song recorded in Uncasville, CT, for inclusion on his live album “Ringo Starr And His All Starr Band Live 2006.” Also, in 2008, a recording was made of the song during Ringo’s live set at the Greek Theatre in Los Angeles, California, the result appearing on the album “Live At The Greek Theatre 2008.”
Song Structure and Style
The Beatles seemed to go to great lengths to infuse some creativity into the structure and arrangement for this song which, to a lot of ears, appears to be a let-down in comparison to the sparkling and innovative songwriting that surrounds it on the album. I heartily implore you to take a closer look at the results so as to show that this is in fact a well-written song with many elements of an impressive performance. I’m not trying to give anyone the "hard sell," but I don’t think that it should be considered a “bad song,” per se, as may be the general opinion. The unfortunate thing here is that, surrounded by the contents of either its British or American album that contains it, it sits among the framework of brilliance. American Beatle fans of the 60’s had a hard transition to the British track listing of the compact disc when, where they expected the beautiful “It’s Only Love,” they got what they considered a "clunky" album-filler sung by Ringo.
Although the structure of the song was no doubt in place back in the late 50’s, we see here another case of a chorus being used as the primary feature, something that was less than usual in their catalog up to this point. The format of the song is ‘chorus/ verse/ chorus/ verse/ chorus (solo)/ verse/ chorus’ (or abababa). Three separate verses with their own lyrics show that a lot of work was put into the writing of the song in getting it to this finished state, Ringo’s “five words” intermingled somewhere within.
A brief four-measure introduction, started off by three leading notes from George before the downbeat, establishes the key of E major and begins what has developed into a true country-and-western flavored piece. Being what Ringo has claimed at the time as being his favorite genre of music, the group was undoubtedly bowing to his favor, possibly purposely altering the previously-written composition to his style. In fact, the habit up to this point had been to cater to a “hillbilly” sound for most of his vocal contributions, which were a Buck Owens cover and two Carl Perkins “rockabilly” classics. (The unreleased “If You’ve Got Trouble” wouldn’t have fit into this mold, not to mention it’s “throwaway” appeal.)
The one-beat of the introduction introduces the full band arrangement as we’ll hear unaltered throughout the song, consisting of John on electric rhythm guitar, Paul on bass and Ringo on drums. George plays an interesting introductory guitar phrase not unlike what we’ll hear almost non-stop throughout the remainder of the two minutes and forty-four seconds.
Just before the first twenty-measure verse begins, we hear the three-part harmony of Ringo, John and Paul come in with the title of the song, which continues in this fashion for the entire verse. In actuality, John and Paul apparently miss the first word, just singing “goes on” the first time around. Just after the first phrase ends with the words “in your heart,” we hear an unidentified voice from the rhythm track give a quick “yelp” of some sort, the first of many in the duration of the song.
The first verse, like the other three, is fourteen measures long. It features Ringo stepping into the spotlight to tell us his story while John and Paul sing background “ooh”s, not unlike what was used in the recently recorded “Michelle.” The melody line used is quite wordy in comparison to the simple phrases contained in the chorus, which sets off a nice contrast. The verse actually appears to have been cut short in structure after the phrase “tell me why,” a sixteen measure format seeming to be more expected. However, extending it another two measures would be even more awkward so its best as it is.
An identical repeat of the chorus comes next with Ringo hitting his snare unusually hard for the first beat. John and Paul once again come in late with the background harmonies, singing only “goes on.” During the breathing space of the last two measures of this chorus we hear some more unidentified mumbling from the rhythm track.
The second verse then appears which follows the same pattern as the first, the most noteworthy feature being what seems to be the voice of John from the rhythm track saying “tell me why?” just after Ringo sings “a girl like you to lie.” And then afterwards, Lennon’s’ infamous exclamation “I already TOLD you why!”
What appears to be another repeat of the chorus comes next, although they cleverly just sing the first phrase in three-part harmony and, after a “wooh” from Paul, they continue the structure of the chorus with George vamping an ad-lib solo rather high in the mix for the remainder of the measures. The only problem here is that the listener probably doesn’t understand the structure of this solo section and it becomes somewhat disorienting, not deciphering the chord changes from the chorus and wondering when it’s going to conclude. Also disorienting is the solo itself which meanders through some phrasings as heard elsewhere in the song, leaving the listener feeling that he’s not sure what he’s doing. Ringo is also heard, presumably in the rhythm track, humming/singing along to the chorus to keep himself and the group in time.
A final identically-structured verse now comes in which has as its feature the erratic rhythm guitar playing of John Lennon, his playing habitually going into loud staccato “chops” throughout its duration. George just plays quiet assorted fills in the background as if he’s not sure what to do.
This is followed by the final chorus which is characterized by Ringo banging away loudly on his snare drum, noticeably different from the rest of the song. While this doesn’t appear to be an edit in the rhythm track (as could be suggested), it is probably just his way of winding the song down climactically. This last chorus is actually followed by another four measures that acts as a conclusion to the song. George’s guitar playing goes diminished while Ringo quietly repeats the final phrase “in your mind” from, presumably, the rhythm track. An overdubbed ending guitar flourish from George (unheard in the mono mix) brings the song to a conclusion with a mighty crash on a syncopated beat. The unfortunate final chord sounds out-of-tune but, with the time constraints, was deemed suitable enough.
Ringo’s drum playing kept the country swagger going without variation throughout the proceedings except for the ending cymbal crash. His forte on this song is his vocal work which, within the small amount of range written into his part, is done amazingly well. He keeps on pitch very well with some slight reaching for the notes in the choruses that actually work nicely with the country feel of the song. Arguably his best vocal performance up to this point.
George is very to the fore on this song, channeling Carl Perkins for his flavored runs that ooze throughout the arrangement. His "high in the mix" guitar work, while not always confidently played, show him being able to ad-lib a little more closely to what he was used to in the Cavern/Hamburg days which were seemingly a million years before. Guitar solos were much more structured in their recent recordings of that day, Paul even playing them himself at times.
Speaking of Paul, his "walking" bass work is phenomenal on this song, as are his usual harmony vocals. John’s harmonies are also spot-on, expected from someone proud to have an early songwriting attempt finally see the light of day. John declines the use of the expected acoustic guitar in favor of electric while playing an unusual staccato rhythm pattern which does get a little patchy at times.
Lyrically, the song fits Ringo’s persona perfectly, he always depicting the "sad and lonely" type who is being mistreated somehow by his significant other. Except for the rockers “Boys" and "I Wanna Be Your Man," his vocal songs up to this point are of this nature.
This time around he sees his “future fold” when he spots his girl with another guy. And, to top it off, he had just been with his girl that “morning, waiting for the tides of time” (this Dylan-esque phrase suggested by Ian MacDonald to be the lyrical contribution from Ringo as read in “Revolution In The Head”). The illusion was that everything was fine with their relationship only to find that it was “easy for (her) to lie.” He wonders “what goes on” in a heart and mind that would cheat so openly. He feels that she didn’t even think of him “as someone with a name,” wondering whether she really wanted to maintain their romance on the sly or whether she meant 'to break his heart and watch him die.' Poor guy!
At least the next time he sings, he’ll be in a happy “Yellow Submarine!”
US picture sleeve
On February 15th, 1966, America got its first glimpse of “What Goes On?” as the b-side of Capitol’s first and only make-shift single of the year, pairing it with “Nowhere Man” as the a-side. While this a-side peaked at #3 on the Billboard pop chart, “What Goes On?” did get a placement on the chart as well, although it only made it up to #81.
Because of force of habit, Capitol printed the songwriting credit as “John Lennon – Paul McCartney” before they were informed that Ringo was also involved in the writing of the song. Later pressings showed the credit as “Lennon – McCartney – Starkey,” but since the popularity of the record had peaked by that time, the majority of the circulated copies have the earlier credit, making the “Starkey” copies much rarer today.
A little over four months later, on June 20th, 1966, “What Goes On?’ got its first US album release on Capitol’s “Yesterday…And Today.” Positioned in the not-so-flattering position of next to last on the album, in-between the powerhouse tracks “We Can Work It Out” and “Day Tripper,” it was much easier to dismiss as album filler than it was in Britain where it started off side two of “Rubber Soul.” "Yesterday...And Today" was then released on January 21st, 2014, as an individual compact disc, both the mono and stereo versions of the album being included on a single CD. Incidentally, this release featured both the "trunk" cover and the "butcher" cover.
Sometime in 1967, Capitol released Beatles music on a brand new but short-lived format called "Playtapes." These tape cartidges did not have the capability to include entire albums, so two truncated four-song versions of "Yesterday...And Today" were released in this portable format, "What Goes On?" being on one of these. These "Playtapes" are highly collectable today.
Speaking of “Rubber Soul,” its first compact disc release was on April 30th, 1987 and featured the new 1986 George Martin stereo mix of “What Goes On?” The CD was then remastered and re-released on September 9th, 2009.
On January 24th, 1996, the Capitol single was re-released in the Cema series “For Jukeboxes Only.” This original single was printed on green vinyl and is quite the find today.
September 9th, 2009 was the release date for the box set “The Beatles In Mono” which, in the case of all of the “Rubber Soul” tracks, “What Goes On?” is featured in both the original 1965 mono and stereo mixes.
On July 7th, 2008, a live performance of the song was included on the album “Ringo Starr & His All Starr Band Live 2006.” Also, his album “Live At The Greek Theatre 2008,” which came out on July 27th, 2010, features a new rendition of “What Goes On?”
Although The Beatles continued to feature a Ringo vocal during their live performances after “Rubber Soul” had been released, they continued playing “Act Naturally” in late 1965 and then delved back to the 1963 rocker “I Wanna Be Your Man” throughout 1966. They apparently didn’t feel “What Goes On?” had the required enthusiastic stage presence and decided to by-pass the song entirely from live performances.
Even Ringo himself performed the song sparingly on stage in later years. Although he had begun touring with his “All-Starr Band” in 1989, he didn’t include the song until his 2006 and 2008 tours, omitting it from his set lists once again thereafter.
It seemed only natural that, given Ringo’s penchant for country music, the group would take their new "original compositions only" policy and concoct a C&W song for him to sing for their current album. The previous albums’ “Act Naturally” worked well enough for Lennon and McCartney to adapt a previously written song to that genre of music, going as far as mimicking the rhythm and style of the Buck Owens classic right down to the three quarter-note guitar introduction. Although “What Goes On?” lacks the confidence and sheen of the previous Ringo song, it still stands as testimony of The Beatles’ chameleon-like ability to convincingly tackle any task needed.
“What Goes On?”
Written by: John Lennon / Paul McCartney / Richard Starkey
Song Written: 1957 to November 4, 1965
Song Recorded: November 4, 1965
First US Release Date: February 15, 1966
US Single Release: Capitol #5587 (b-side to “Nowhere Man”)
Highest Chart Position: #81
British Album Release: Parlophone #PCS 3075 “Rubber Soul”
Key: E major
Producer: George Martin
Engineers: Norman Smith, Ken Scott, Graham Platt
Instrumentation (most likely):
Ringo Starr – Lead Vocals, Drums (1964 Ludwig Super Classic Black Oyster Pearl)
George Harrison – Lead Guitar (1963 Gretsch 6119 Tennessean)
Paul McCartney - Bass Guitar (1964 Rickenbacker 4001S), Harmony Vocals
John Lennon - Rhythm Guitar (1964 Rickenbacker 325), Harmony Vocals
Written and compiled by Dave Rybaczewski
Sign Up Below for our MONTHLY BEATLES TRIVIA QUIZ!