Search by Keyword
(John Lennon – Paul McCartney)
The Beatles versatility is something that may not have been noticed by the screaming teenage girls of the early days of Beatlemania, but was a key ingredient to their enduring career. While most of their British contemporaries, such as The Rolling Stones, The Kinks, and The Dave Clark Five, could thrash out their own brand of rock and roll very convincingly, they appeared somewhat awkward when trying to reveal a softer side. Their attempts at this were most likely in imitation of what The Beatles were doing anyway. Would “As Tears Go By” by the Stones, “Tired Of Waiting For You” by the Kinks or “Because” by the DC5 existed if The Beatles weren’t setting the blueprint ahead of time? The Stones emphatically answer this question with their Beatles-copy-cat career throughout most of the 60’s. And who could blame them?
Truth be told, The Beatles were setting the benchmark for other acts to follow, even though it may have been unbeknownst to them. The Beatles were simply versatile. They could rock and roll themselves right off the stage, but that was only a portion of their intention. They naturally had a love for many different styles of music, including the softer side. Lennon himself stated that The Beatles “never stuck to one style; They never just did blues, or just rock. We loved all music,” even the “sentimental things” as John called them.
Their early Cavern years reflected this, showing them crooning adult-sounding classics like “Red Sails In The Sunset,” “Till There Was You” and “Falling In Love Again” right in-between “Twist And Shout” and “Sweet Little Sixteen.” What was so incredible was how convincingly they delivered such a vast array of musical styles on stage.
Even the softer side of their musical tastes came from their love of many different genres, such as in the case of “This Boy,” which combines their love of the doo-wop sound of the 50’s with the incredible influence that Smokey Robinson and The Miracles had on John Lennon. Once again, as fame brought them to America, we see how natural and convincing The Beatles were at portraying their softer side. They weren’t simply throwing in a mellow song just to relieve the rocking tension of the album, or in order to appease their manager or record label, but because it was another ingredient of the whole. It was part of them, and that continued to be heard throughout their career.
The songwriting maturity displayed on “This Boy” could hardly have gone unnoticed by the curious adult onlookers to the groups’ second appearance on the Ed Sullivan Show on February 16th, 1964. While their first appearance on the show (February 9th) brought forward the excellent “Till There Was You,” the evidence was clear by the second week that The Beatles were much more than head-swinging long-haired noise makers. While detractors abounded, honest minded parents had to admit there was unmistakable talent behind the gimmicks. And when their daughters came home with the “Meet The Beatles!” album in early 1964, the third track on side one reinforced that fact.
Evidence of the sophistication of the songs’ melody was revealed by The Beatles’ producer George Martin, who chose to record and release an instrumental version of the song under the title “Ringo’s Theme (This Boy).” Used as a backdrop to the scene of a sullen Ringo Starr wandering around the waterfront in the movie “A Hard Day’s Night,” it was issued as a single in the US and even made the Billboard single charts (number 53). This only adds to the credibility of the Lennon / McCartney songwriting team, being that an enduring melodic chord structure and melody line could stand alone and win the hearts of adult audiences as well as teenagers. Upon recollecting his personal songwriting abilities during the Beatle years, Lennon recalls “This Boy” and states, “I was writing melody with the best of them.” On that we all can agree.
"Just my attempt at writing one of those three-part harmony Smokey Robinson songs," Lennon explains about "This Boy." With this statement one can assume that the song was written entirely by John. He also states as such in a 1972 Hit Parader magazine interview. However, Paul gives a vivid and convincing recollection otherwise. He describes the song as another “hotel-bedroom” song written when they “had a couple of hours to kill” before getting ready for another performance sometime in September 1963. Although we don’t know the exact day, in this case we know the exact time the song was written, as McCartney recalls arriving “around one o’clock” in the afternoon, which would take them to around three o’clock when the song was considered complete.
As a footnote concerning whether the song was completely written in this two-hour writing session in September, we need to consider the actual session ‘takes’ of the song in the recording studio the following month. At some point during the recording sessions for the song, a guitar solo was featured instead of the vocals in the bridge, which could suggest that the lyrics in the bridge were written during the recording sessions. Although this is possible, it seems unlikely because of the intricacies of the melody line and lyrics as we’ve come to know. It is also unlikely that they were written during the recording sessions because of the approximate hour’s time that was used to completely record the song on that day. This being the case, it can be accurately assumed that “This Boy” was indeed written completely in the “hotel-bedroom” in two hours.
McCartney’s account of this September writing session is uncharacteristically vivid, remembering the “position of the beds, John and I sitting on twin beds, the G-Plan furniture, the British hotel with olive green and orange everywhere, that marvelous combination, the colors of vomit.” In that setting they fulfilled their desire to write a close-harmony song patterned after the three-part harmony they used in the Phil Spector written “To Know Her Is To Love Her” during the Cavern Club days. According to Harrison, Lennon patterned the song after the Smokey Robinson and The Miracles song “I’ve Been Good To You,” which has a similar chord pattern, melody and arrangement. McCartney describes “This Boy” as “quite a departure” for them, saying that they “never actually tried to write something” with three-part harmonies before.
On that day, they naturally worked out a two-part harmony for the song first, and then afterward worked out a third harmony for George to sing. McCartney at one point had claimed that his father had taught the Beatles how to do three-part harmony, but Harrison protests this claim. After describing “This Boy” as one of their “three-part harmony numbers,” he explains, “when you think back to early rock and roll there was always stuff like Frankie Lymon and The Teenagers, The Everly Brothers, The Platters. Everybody had harmonies; it was natural to sing a harmony sometimes.” That natural ability was, of course, refined by producer George Martin in the studio. “They always experimented with close harmony singing,” Martin recalled, “all I did was change the odd note.” This was done in the studio with all three vocalists sitting with Martin at the piano while he made small but necessary adjustments in the notes they sang. Meanwhile, Ringo sat at the back of the studio smoking a cigarette and reading a comic book.
William Mann, the music critic for The London Times, mentioned “This Boy” in a flattering but ostentatious review of the Beatles music in late 1963. McCartney, referring to his article, mentioned Mann’s reference to “the ‘pandiatonic clusters’ that came flying out of us at the end of ‘This Boy.’ We hadn’t been conscious of any of that.” Lennon and McCartney may have lacked proper musical training, but they were trained by listening to and studying the music they were exposed to, in which they must have paid more than the usual attention to.
The Beatles in EMI Recording Studio Two
Both sides of their fifth British single were recorded during the same three hour recording session on October 17th, 1963 at EMI Studio Two in London. This was the same historic recording session that introduced the techniques of four-track recording to the Beatles, having recorded “I Want To Hold Your Hand” the same way on that day (as well as the first Beatles Christmas Record of speech and an aborted attempt at a remake of “You Really Got A Hold On Me”). Having done these other three items first, “This Boy” was last on the agenda for the day, which approximately comprised the final hour of the session (9:00 to 10:00 pm).
It took fifteen takes of the song (most of them complete) to perfect, although there was more to be done to get it to the complete state as we know it. The vocals were recorded, by the Beatles request, with all three vocalists huddled around one microphone. The finished version appears to be an edit of takes 14 and 15, which is brutally spliced together just before the final verse, making an obvious abrupt edit that is verynoticeable in the finished product (although performed with flowing precision when done on stage, as can be seen on their Ed Sullivan Show appearance).
Two overdubs (take 16 and 17) were then recorded, which comprise George Harrison performing octave guitar fills at the end of the song. These overdubs were added to the end of take 15.
One more session was needed to get the song in a releasable condition. A mixing session, attended by George Martin and engineer Norman Smith only, was held four days later on October 21st. This day was arranged to create the mono mixes necessary for releasing their fifth British single. They created two mono mixes from take 15 of the recording session and then performed an edit of both of those mixes to get the final version, creating the fade out that is heard on the released recording. It was decided at this stage, for an unknown reason, to fade the end of the song instead of the full ending The Beatles recorded in the studio. Needless to say, The Beatles continued to perform the full ending on stage throughout the songs’ performance life.
No stereo mix of the song was recorded at this time, since the song was only slated as a single in Britain. However, entirely by accident, the song was given its’ first stereo mix on November 10th, 1966. A telephone call was made to Abbey Road to inform them of the line-up for the first “Greatest Hits” package which was scheduled to be released in December of that year. By mistake, the phone message related that “This Boy” would be on the album so it would need to have a stereo mix made for album release. The message should have indicated the song “Bad Boy,” which was not released in Britain at that time and would be included on the album, which was titled “A Collection Of Beatles Oldies,” as an enticement for fans to buy an album of songs they probably already owned. Before the mistake was corrected, the four-track tape of “This Boy” was dug out and treated to its’ first and only stereo mix. Two stereo mixes were made from the edited take 15 of the song, and then both of those mixes were edited together to create the full stereo mix.
Subsequently, the mix used for the stereo version of “Meet The Beatles!” in the US was actually a duophonic (or fake) stereo mix created by Capitol records. This fake stereo mix continued to be used in America well after 1966 because the true stereo mix that was made then didn’t surface until October of 1988, with the release of “Past Masters, Volume One.”
“This Boy” did surface at EMI studios on one other occasion. That occasion was on June 3rd, 1964, when The Beatles were auditioning Jimmy Nicol to replace an ailing Ringo Starr for the beginning of their first world tour. It would be necessary to see if Jimmy could handle the subdued drum arrangement Ringo played on this song as well as ‘rock-out’ on “I Saw Her Standing There” and “Long Tall Sally.” Apparently he could, because 27 hours later they were in Copenhagen on the first date of their tour.
Song Structure and Style
Like the vast majority of the early Beatles catalog, “This Boy” is written in the 'verse/ verse/ bridge/ verse' configuration (or aaba). The group showed themselves somewhat adventurous by delving into a full-on 6/8 waltz-like time signature for the first time in their career, not too unlike the ¾ time signature used throughoutmost of “A Taste Of Honey” on the first album. Although a guitar solo is attempted at some point in the recording process, it is decided instead not to feature a solo at all. Because of the elongated 16 bar verses and bridge, a repeat of the bridge and final verse, as many Beatles songs did up to this point in their career, was not done.
The song starts out with a strummed three chord precursor by Lennon to set the melancholy mood for the song. This three chord pattern actually fills what would be the last three quarters of a first bar which, byextension, brings the introduction of the song to five bars instead of the expected four. The following four bars are basically the four chord pattern that we will be hearing throughout all three verses, but set the mood quite nicely.
Right on the one beat of the first verse, we dive headlong into the impressive three-part harmony which will eventually permeate all three verses. The eleventh bar of the verse consists of a dramatic break which has become a feature of a lot of the early Beatles songs. This is followed by another break on the twelfth bar, both breaks becoming a highlight for the signature lyric hook-line of the song.
A second verse is then performed which is structurally identical to the first with the exception of the chords played on the last two bars. This change in the chord pattern is to facilitate a transition into the climactic bridge, which creates the necessary anticipation and suits that transition perfectly.
The 16 bar bridge actually becomes the highlight of the song, with an uplifting yet pleading melody line rising higher than anything heard in the verses. The chord pattern as well as the actual chords played is strikingly dissimilar to the verses but yet create an alluring counterpart creating an exciting tension to the song. Each chord in the progression changes every two measures instead of one per measure as the verses do. All the while, harmony background vocals create an atmospheric backdrop to Lennon’s gut-wrenching solo vocal, which climax into another break for the 15th and 16th bar while Lennon holds out the word “cry” for a full two measures.
(As a footnote, the word “cry” has been a constant feature of the lyrics of Lennon throughout his Beatles career, spanning from “Ask Me Why” through “I’ll Cry Instead,” “Cry Baby Cry” and even “I Am The Walrus.” Some may claim that this may be an indication of his emotional state throughout the sixties and of the loss of his mother early in his life. But we’ll leave that for another book and author.)
The identically structured third verse with different lyrics then is played, leaving us with the final satisfying lyrical intent of the saga: “…if this boy gets you back again.” The conclusion of the song, or ‘outro,’ consists of the title of the song sung in three part harmony repeatedly with the same chord pattern of the verses while an octave guitar passage is repeated in between the gaps while the song fades into the distance.
An instrumental analysis shows Lennon primarily strumming his acoustic guitar on the first and fourth beats of each measure, but with feeling, which provide a suitable backdrop to the song. He sings the lowest of the three-part harmonies in the verses, which make this the lead vocal line, being that he’s revealed to be the lead singer during the bridge. During this bridge, John sings a melody line that is a full octave higher than he sings in the verses, which adds dynamic force and excitement. The lead vocals of this impressive climatic bridge even impressed McCartney, who many years later stated about the song “nice middle, John sang that great.”
Paul’s bass work, although low in the mix like a lot of the early Beatles songs, is impressive through his use of small three note runs and octave jumps throughout the verses whenever he wasn’t singing. He seemed to know when not to do bass runs, as he played very rudimentary bass notes during the bridge, which shifted all focus on the lead vocal line and backing harmonies. Ever the perfectionist, Paul sings his usual higher harmony throughout the song, and always in good pitch.
George plays electric rhythm guitar using a more prominent swing rhythm during the verses utilizing all six beats of each measure, which provides a nice contrast to the simple chord strumming of Lennon. Harrison then drops the swing rhythm during the climatic bridge and just plays guitar ‘chops’ on each beat, which also provides a suitable contrast for the song. He then ends the song with his overdubbed octave guitar lines whichare heard as the song fades. His middle harmony part is also performed with great precision, which shows how rehearsed and refined the vocals were at the time of recording.
Ringo’s drum work for the song consists primarily of riding his partially closed set of hi-hats during the verses using the same swing rhythm played by Harrison. The contrast needed for the bridge of the song also involves the drums, as Ringo performs a rudimentary full kit waltz-like pattern until the break, where thereby Starr returns to his hi-hat beat until the song fades.
Lennon liked to dismiss the lyrics to most of his early Beatles work, stating about this song that there was “nothing in the lyrics, just a sound and a harmony.” But there is more to this formulaic ‘teen’ lyric than meets the eye. As was common to his early lyrics, John is portraying himself as a loser. His girl was taken away from him by someone who, the singer claims, “won’t be happy till he’s seen (her) cry.” John then says that he would never feel differently about the girl if he could get her “back again.” Lennon’s lyrics depicting wallowing in misery continued to occur occasionally through 1965, being hinted at even in “Nowhere Man.” John’s ‘inner anguish,’ as many would call it, seemed to disappear as his lyrics became much more expressive and picturesque from 1966 onward, no doubt influenced by Bob Dylan’s encouragement to expand in his lyric writing and by drugs (or probably both).
By today’s standards, the use of the word ‘boy’ to depict the male suitor sounds extremely dated, but was quite acceptable by 1963/64 terms. As early as the ‘summer of love’ of 1967, that dynamic changed. It would no longer be acceptable to refer to the male partner in any relationship as a ‘boy’ by any stretch of the imagination. As evidence, a little over four years later, Herb Alpert had a number one hit with the similarly titled “This Guy’s In Love With You.” That ‘guy’ was no longer a ‘boy.’
In November of 1963, it appeared probable that the song “This Boy” would be released as the B-side to their first Capitol records single and, therefore, be catapulted to great exposure on radio and in the homes of millions of teenagers. After all, this was the B-side to their 1.25 million selling British single “I Want To Hold Your Hand,” and the other three American singles (released on other labels) had the same B-sides as their British counterparts thus far. As events transpired, this was not to be.
The powers that be at Capitol decided to feature a similarly rocking Beatles song on the flip side of the first single to create what they felt would create a better first impression. They went as far as the first song on their first British album “Please Please Me” to find a suitable replacement, “I Saw Her Standing There.” While history shows that this choice may have been the best, one can only wonder what difference the appearance of “This Boy” as the flip side would have made. (Capitol substituted the B-side of only one other British single, which was later in 1964 with the single “A Hard Day’s Night.” They substituted the mellow “Things We Said Today” with the energetic soundtrack song “I Should Have Known Better.”)
To say that “This Boy” did not make the cut as a flip side on an American single was not to say that US fans could not get the song as a single. Capitol of Canada released a couple of unique singles of their own creation in early 1964 to capitalize on the immense success of Beatlemania in that country. The second of which was “All My Loving” which paired “This Boy” as its flip side. Because of the clamor for ‘anything Beatles’ in the states, America imported copies of this single into the country and thereby created another charted hit on the Billboard singles chart. “All My Loving” charted through late March and all of April, peaking at number 45. This is a worthy mention, but not an actual American release.
The first release of the song on American shores was the famous “Meet The Beatles!” album released on January 20th, 1964. It appears as the third track of side one after the replacement B-side “I Saw Her Standing There.” The position on the album appears to be Capitol’s recognition of the ‘star quality’ of the song. This album was finally released on an individual compact disc on January 21st, 2014, both the mono and stereo mixes being contained on a single CD.
Three rare releases of the song also should be documented here. A jukebox version of the “Meet The Beatles!” album (#SXA 2047) was released in January of 1964 to promote non-single tracks from the album in jukeboxes in the US. “This Boy” was featured as the second song on side one. In February of 1964, “The Beatles Open End Interview” (#PRO 2548) was sent to disc jockeys around the country to be played on the air to simulate a personal interview with the group. Side two contained two non-single tracks, the first of which was “This Boy.” Also in February of 1964, a promotional disc was prepared by Capitol entitled “Great New Releases From The Sound Capitol Of The World” which featured “This Boy.” This album was issued to radio stations to encourage broadcast an entire side of the album at a time, since both sides of the album featured a variety of Capitol recording artists. All three of these releases are very hard to find and quite collectible, but nonetheless should be considered the second, third and fourth third release of the song.
The song’s fifth release was on May 11th, 1964, on Capitol’s first attempt at an extended-play single (EP) entitled “Four By The Beatles.” The idea of the EP was to capitalize on the minor success of the songs contained on the two Canadian singles that made the US charts. “This Boy” was featured as the first song of side two. The record sold extremely less than any of the Capitol singles or albums released thus far, showing that EP potential in the US at this time was not worth pursuing. The EP charted on the Billboard singles chart for three weeks in June of 1964, peaking at number 92. Another reason for its’ failure was probably that all four of these songs were released on a Capitol album by this time and therefore offered nothing new to Beatles fans.
Sometime in 1967, Capitol released Beatles music on a brand new but short-lived format called "Playtapes." These tape cartidges did not have the capability to include entire albums, so two truncated four-song versions of "Meet The Beatles" were released in this portable format, "This Boy" being on one of these releases. These "Playtapes" are highly collectable today.
Since the song was not a hit single in the US, it didn’t make the grade to appear on the ‘greatest hits’ package “1962-1966” (the Red Album), nor was it a ‘rock and roll’ song, which was a prerequisite for the highly successful double LP “Rock n’ Roll Music.” The song’s sixth release would therefore have to wait until October 21st, 1977 with the release of the double album “Love Songs,” in which it fit just perfectly. This compilation, released during the current wave of post-Beatlemania, only managed to peak at number 24 on the Billboard charts, although it appears to have sold 3 million units before it’s deletion from Capitol’s roster in the late 80’s.
March 7th, 1988 became the date of the seventh U.S. release of “This Boy,” which finally premiered the stereo mix of the song that was done nearly 22 years earlier for the British album “A Collection Of Beatles Oldies.” (A 1976 Canadian single was actually the first release of this stereo mix which did not become available in America until twelve years later!) The album “Past Masters, Volume One” was released, along with “Past Masters, Volume Two,” to complete The Beatles discography available on CD for the first time. This compilation was also released as a vinyl two-album set in the US on October 21st, 1988. Both volumes of "Past Masters" were then combined on September 9th, 2009 into one volume simply entitled "Past Masters."
On June 30th, 1992, the stereo mix of “This Boy” also appeared on a bonus disc included in the box set “Compact Disc EP Collection,” which was the CD version of the British released vinyl box set that came out back in 1981.
Although Capitol originally passed on the idea of "This Boy" being the B-side to "I Want To Hold Your Hand" in America, they did, on one rare occasion, place both songs together on a single. In March of 1994, Capitol released this single for their Cema "For Jukebox Only" series, and on clear vinyl to boot. Find this one and you have an interesting collectors' piece.
The eighth release of the song was on November 21st, 1995 on the highly successful “Anthology 1” double disc. Disc two contains the version of “This Boy” that they performed on the British television show, The Morecambe and Wise Show, on December 2nd, 1963. This compilation was the first official occurrence of an album release debuting in the number one spot on the Billboard albums chart. It spent a total of 29 weeks on the charts and reached a sales figure of over 3 ½ million.
The song had a ninth release on December 12th, 1995 as a bonus track to the newly recorded Beatles song “Free As A Bird.” This version of “This Boy” was actually two original takes of the song made on October 17th, 1963 (takes 12 and 13). These takes are humorous because of the background vocalists getting their “this boys” and “that boys” mixed up, which have the song break down with laughter. The single peaked at number six on the Billboard charts.
The re-release of the “Meet The Beatles!” album then appeared in the four-disc compilation “The Capitol Albums, Vol. 1” on November 15th, 2004. Paired with the albums “The Beatles’ Second Album,” “Something New” and “Beatles ’65,” it comprised both the original stereo and mono mixes of the albums. Therefore, the original “fake” duophonic stereo version of “This Boy” is contained on this release. This box set peaked at number 35 on the Billboard charts in its’ first charted week.
On September 9th, 2009, the box set "The Beatles In Mono" was released which featured a srystal clear re-mastered mono version of "This Boy" on its disc "Mono Masters."
November 11th, 2013 was the release date for the album "On Air - Live At The BBC Volume 2." This included a version of "This Boy" as recorded on December 17th, 1963 for the radio program "Saturday Club." Even though this was intended for radio transmission only, they took pains to double-track John's lead vocals to give it the same depth as heard on the released version. Interestingly, listen for John to accidentally sing "that boy" instead of "this boy" at the beginning of the final verse.
Also released around this date was a fourteen-track sampler of the above album for promotional purposes, "This Boy" being included therein.
The Beatles at The London Palladium, January 1964
“This Boy” became a common fixture in the groups’ stage act from December 1963 through June 1964, which included their historic premier in the US as well as many other countries.
The aforementioned “Morecambe and Wise Show” on December 2nd, 1963 appears to be the first performance of the song, which then culminated into additional British television appearances in promotion of their recently released single. The song became a permanent feature in their British concerts, including their “Sunday Night at the London Palladium” appearance on January 12th, 1964. It was also in the set list during their January stint at the Olympia Theater in Paris.
February 1964 brought The Beatles to America and, with them they brought “This Boy” to their Washington Coliseum concert on February 11th, their appearance at Carnegie Hall on February 12th, and their second Ed Sullivan Show appearance on February 16th.
When the first leg of their first world tour began (with Jimmy Nicols on drums) on June 4th, the song was still in the set list. They performed the song in Copenhagen, Adelaide and Melbourne, Australia (with a returned Ringo) before finally retiring the song for good on June 17th, 1964.
Their first of two performances of the song for BBC radio was on December 17th, 1963 for the show “Saturday Club,” which was broadcast on December 21st. On February 28th, 1964, they recorded the song for the second installment of “From Us To You,” which aired on March 30th.
What truly made “This Boy” a remarkable recording, in addition to the tight harmony interplay between John, Paul and George, was the sheer liberation of the bridge which accentuated the drama of the song. This was highlighted to great effect on stage when, as on their Ed Sullivan Show performance of the song, they all huddled around one microphone to portray their oneness of mind as a band.
That the group could afford to virtually throw away such a brilliantly constructed song as a B-side says a lot about the quality of the material they were writing at the time. They were truly on a roll, finding national and international fame which was fueling their creative output. Knowing that the song became a certified number one hit in Canada as the B-side of “All My Loving,” one can only speculate how well it would have been received if it was released similarly in the US. But, nonetheless, there it stands as testimony to the brilliance of the early Lennon/McCartney songwriting team.
Written by: John Lennon / Paul McCartney
- Song Written: September 1963
- Song Recorded: October 17th, 1963
- First US Release Date: January 20th, 1964
- First US Album Release: Capitol #ST-2047 “Meet The Beatles!”
- US Single Release: Capitol #SXA 2047 (Meet The Beatles Jukebox EP)
- Highest Chart Position: #92 (Four By The Beatles EP)
- British Album Release: Parlophone #PCSP 721 “Love Songs”
- Length: 2:13
- Key: D major
- Producer: George Martin
- Engineers: Norman Smith, Geoff Emerick
Instrumentation (most likely):
- John Lennon – Lead Vocals, Rhythm Guitar (1962 Gibson J160E)
- Paul McCartney - Bass Guitar (1963 Hofner 500/1), Harmony Vocals
- George Harrison – Lead Guitar (1962 Gretsch 6122 Country Gentleman), Harmony Vocals
- Ringo Starr – Drums (1963 Ludwig Downbeat Black Oyster Pearl)
Written and compiled by Dave Rybaczewski
Sign Up Below for our MONTHLY BEATLES TRIVIA QUIZ!